Journalist reviews

16 hub comparisons and 44 single-hub reviews from the press, published in 2025 and 2026. See who won each test, then read the original article.

Updated November 2026

Who wins the tests

Ranked by outright wins in the 16 hub comparisons from 2025 and 2026. = one test win (overall, first place or joint winner). Category picks are use-case awards in the same tests. Tap a tile to see its articles.

Also picked once: Amazon Echo Hub (PCWorld), Sonoff Zigbee Bridge Ultra (Diginytt), Plejd Gateway (SmartaTest), Homematic IP and homee (CHIP). Circuit & Chime names no overall winner. Counts are by brand, so Home Assistant includes its Green and Yellow boxes.

ArticleWinner or resultMedia outletCountryYearLink
ComparisonSmart-Home-Systeme im Test 2026: Drei Systeme im VergleichThree systems tested for different use cases. Full recommendations are in the article.Homematic IP for security. homee for modular expansion.CHIP Germany2026Read Smart-Home-Systeme im Test 2026: Drei Systeme im Vergleich (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonHomey Pro vs Hubitat: Which Local Hub?Explicitly based on manufacturer information.No universal winnerHomey Pro for broader built-in radios and a polished app; Hubitat for local automation at lower costCircuit & Chime International2026Read Homey Pro vs Hubitat: Which Local Hub? (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonBäst i test: Bästa hubben till ditt smarta hem system 2026Also ranks Aqara Hub M3, Homey Pro mini and Fibaro Home Center 3.Homey Pro (2026) — overall, 5/5Homey Bridge — best budget, 4/5; Sonoff Zigbee Bridge Ultra — value pick, 3.5/5Diginytt Sweden2026Read Bäst i test: Bästa hubben till ditt smarta hem system 2026 (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonTop 7 hubs de domóticaOther use-case picks: Hue Bridge Pro for Hue lighting, Aeotec Smart Home Hub 2 for SmartThings, SwitchBot Hub 2 for IR and Homey Bridge for Homey Cloud.Aqara Hub M3 — ranked firstHomey Pro (Early 2023) — second; Home Assistant Green — thirdDomotikum Spain2026Read Top 7 hubs de domótica (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonSmart Home Zentrale: 7 Systeme von homee bis Home AssistantPublisher explicitly says it did not test these seven systems firsthand.Homey Pro (2026) — editorial pick for mixed deviceshandgetestet Germany2026Read Smart Home Zentrale: 7 Systeme von homee bis Home Assistant (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonTop 10: Die besten Smart-Home-Systeme im Test – Home Assistant überragt alleHome Assistant leads the ranking. Hub and platform recommendations depend on the installation.Home Assistant leads the rankingheise Bestenlisten Germany2026Read Top 10: Die besten Smart-Home-Systeme im Test – Home Assistant überragt alle (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonI've researched and tested the best smart hubs to simplify your home automation – these are my top 6 recommendationsThe article also lists an 8-inch Amazon touchscreen as “Amazon Echo”; precise model label unclear.Homey Pro — overallIKEA Dirigera — app design; Philips Hue Bridge Pro — mid-range; Samsung SmartThings Hub V2 — budgetHomebuilding & Renovating United Kingdom2026Read I've researched and tested the best smart hubs to simplify your home automation – these are my top 6 recommendations (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonParas älykodin keskus 2026 – hubit ja bridget vertailussaUse-case recommendations.Homey Pro — mixed technologiesHome Assistant Green — customization; Aqara Hub M3 — Aqara devices; Philips Hue Bridge — lighting; IKEA Dirigera — IKEA homesKodinäly Finland2026Read Paras älykodin keskus 2026 – hubit ja bridget vertailussa (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonSmart Home Hubs of 2026Two dedicated hubs earn category awards.Aeotec Smart Home Hub — overallAqara Hub M2 — infrared controlSafeWise United States2026Read Smart Home Hubs of 2026 (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonSmart-home-hubsUnfiltered hub category; filtered derivatives excluded.Home Assistant Green — best choice, 8.8Smart Systemen Netherlands2026Read Smart-home-hubs (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonHome Assistant vs Homey: welke smart home hub kies je?The guide uses Green as its lower-cost Home Assistant hardware example.Homey Pro — ease of useHome Assistant — control and flexibilitySmart Systemen Netherlands2026Read Home Assistant vs Homey: welke smart home hub kies je? (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonStort test: Bästa hubben till smarta hem systemHome Assistant is a platform-level recommendation; hardware is discussed separately.Homey Pro — easiest for many brandsHome Assistant — most controlSmarta Hem Test Sweden2026Read Stort test: Bästa hubben till smarta hem system (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonSmart hem-hubb bäst i test 2026: tre olika produkter på samma hyllaEight dedicated hubs and bridges compared.Homey Pro — overallAqara M3 — remote-controlled equipment; Home Assistant Green — owner control; Aqara M100 — budget; IKEA Dirigera — affordable expansion; Homey Pro mini — homes without older radios; Hue Bridge Pro — Hue; Plejd Gateway — PlejdSmartaTest Sweden2026Read Smart hem-hubb bäst i test 2026: tre olika produkter på samma hylla (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonÄlykoti-keskusyksikkö vertailu 2026: Parhaat älykodin ohjausyksiköt suomalaiseen kotiinThe article awards Yellow the highest numerical score (9.5/10) and names Homey Pro best overall (9/10).Homey Pro — overallSamsung SmartThings Station — value; Home Assistant Yellow — advanced users; Aqara Hub M3 — Apple users; Hubitat Elevation C-8 — Z-WaveTurvallinen Koti Finland2026Read Älykoti-keskusyksikkö vertailu 2026: Parhaat älykodin ohjausyksiköt suomalaiseen kotiin (opens in a new tab)
ReviewBosch Smart Home Controller Zentrale im TestReviews setup and the central controller’s role within the Bosch system.Bosch Smart Home ControllerAlltag-Digital Germany2026Read Bosch Smart Home Controller Zentrale im Test (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSONOFF NSPanel Pro Gen2 touch control panel review with eWeLink and Home Assistant - CNX SoftwareTests the wall controller and hub through eWeLink and Home Assistant.Sonoff NSPanel Pro Gen2CNX Software Thailand2026Read SONOFF NSPanel Pro Gen2 touch control panel review with eWeLink and Home Assistant - CNX Software (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSwitchBot「ハブ3」レビュー スマートホーム機器をダイヤル操作、センサーとの組み合わせも 使ってわかった魅力と注意点Likes the physical controls and sensor automation; flags cost for simple setups.SwitchBot Hub 3Fav-Log by ITmedia Japan2026Read SwitchBot「ハブ3」レビュー スマートホーム機器をダイヤル操作、センサーとの組み合わせも 使ってわかった魅力と注意点 (opens in a new tab)
ReviewTapo H500 Smart HomeBase review: The smarter smart homeTests the smart-home and camera base; review updated in January 2026.TP-Link Tapo H500 Smart HomeBaseGadgetGuy Australia2026Read Tapo H500 Smart HomeBase review: The smarter smart home (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSMLIGHT SMHUB NANO Review: The fully independent Linux smart home hubTests the hub as an independent Linux host for home-automation services.SMLIGHT SMHUB Nano MG24Haade France2026Read SMLIGHT SMHUB NANO Review: The fully independent Linux smart home hub (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSmart-Home-Zentrale Homey Pro (2026) im Test: Lokal und ohne Cloud-ZwangThe refresh adds memory capacity. Evaluates local control and compatibility limits.Homey Pro (2026)heise Bestenlisten Germany2026Read Smart-Home-Zentrale Homey Pro (2026) im Test: Lokal und ohne Cloud-Zwang (opens in a new tab)
ReviewHomey Pro Mini im Test: Lokale Steuerzentrale als Home-Assistant-AlternativeExamines the smaller local hub as an alternative to Home Assistant.Homey Pro miniheise online Germany2026Read Homey Pro Mini im Test: Lokale Steuerzentrale als Home-Assistant-Alternative (opens in a new tab)
ReviewHomey Pro Mini - veel Homey voor minder geldStrong first hub. Prefers the full Pro for larger installations.Homey Pro miniHelloSmartHome Netherlands2026Read Homey Pro Mini - veel Homey voor minder geld (opens in a new tab)
ReviewReview Homey Pro 2023: jouw nieuwe smart home-centrale?Broad integration and local automation. Reviews the added value and limits of HomeKit support.Homey Pro (Early 2023)iCulture Netherlands2026Read Review Homey Pro 2023: jouw nieuwe smart home-centrale? (opens in a new tab)
ReviewReview: Homey Bridge, geen brug naar HomeKitThe original review finds poor fit for HomeKit users.Homey BridgeiCulture Netherlands2026Read Review: Homey Bridge, geen brug naar HomeKit (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSwitchBotハブ3 レビュー|物理ダイヤル&Matter対応で進化、スマートホーム国内シェアNo.1の中核ハブGives 4.5 overall; highlights physical controls and Matter bridging.SwitchBot Hub 3 4.5/5LIVING TECH Association Japan2026Read SwitchBotハブ3 レビュー|物理ダイヤル&Matter対応で進化、スマートホーム国内シェアNo.1の中核ハブ (opens in a new tab)
ReviewTEST: Homey Pro (2026)Combines devices that would otherwise need separate apps.Homey Pro (2026)Lyd & Bilde Norway2026Read TEST: Homey Pro (2026) (opens in a new tab)
ReviewTEST: Homey Pro mini - Homey Pro mini: Storsbrors ytelse, til halv prisExamines the smaller hub’s coverage relative to the full Homey Pro.Homey Pro miniLyd & Bilde Norway2026Read TEST: Homey Pro mini - Homey Pro mini: Storsbrors ytelse, til halv pris (opens in a new tab)
ReviewZemismart M1 Pro Hub review: Probably not what you're looking forRecommends looking elsewhere due to Thread, IR bridging and software limitations.Zemismart M1 ProMatter Alpha International2026Read Zemismart M1 Pro Hub review: Probably not what you're looking for (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSwitchBot AI Hub review: The smart home hub with an identity crisisJudges its AI hub features immature at the time of review.SwitchBot AI HubMatter Alpha International2026Read SwitchBot AI Hub review: The smart home hub with an identity crisis (opens in a new tab)
ReviewThe Homey Pro is brilliant — which makes its biggest flaw even harder to ignore | Matter AlphaQuestions the value of the full Pro when the mini provides much of the experience for less.Homey ProMatter Alpha International2026Read The Homey Pro is brilliant — which makes its biggest flaw even harder to ignore | Matter Alpha (opens in a new tab)
ReviewHow the SwitchBot Hub 3 became the go-to smart controller in our home | Matter AlphaReports on how the hub’s physical controls fit into daily household use.SwitchBot Hub 3Matter Alpha International2026Read How the SwitchBot Hub 3 became the go-to smart controller in our home | Matter Alpha (opens in a new tab)
ReviewLightwave Link Plus Review - Mighty Gadget Blog Technology News and ReviewsEvaluates the Lightwave gateway and integration improvements. Originally published in 2017.Lightwave Link PlusMighty Gadget United Kingdom2026Read Lightwave Link Plus Review - Mighty Gadget Blog Technology News and Reviews (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSwitchBot AI Hub review: smart home brain or local NVR?Tests the hub’s capabilities alongside the AI Art Frame.SwitchBot AI HubNew Atlas International2026Read SwitchBot AI Hub review: smart home brain or local NVR? (opens in a new tab)
ReviewHands On With the Bond Mate Pro Remote, the Bond Bridge Pro, and the Modern Atomics ColliderInstaller’s hands-on test of the bridge as part of a shade-control setup.Bond Bridge ProResidential Systems United States2026Read Hands On With the Bond Mate Pro Remote, the Bond Bridge Pro, and the Modern Atomics Collider (opens in a new tab)
ReviewRecensione Homey Pro: a cosa serve e come funzionaExplains the controller through the author’s practical smart-home setup.Homey ProSky TG24 Italy2026Read Recensione Homey Pro: a cosa serve e come funziona (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSMHUB Nano MG24 Review: All-in-One Smart HubAssesses its ability to host automation software as well as coordinate radio devices.SMLIGHT SMHUB Nano MG24SmartHomeScene International2026Read SMHUB Nano MG24 Review: All-in-One Smart Hub (opens in a new tab)
ReviewPhilips Hue Bridge Pro review: The ultimate upgrade for Hue usersAssesses the upgrade for an existing Hue installation.Philips Hue Bridge ProT3 United Kingdom2026Read Philips Hue Bridge Pro review: The ultimate upgrade for Hue users (opens in a new tab)
ReviewBroadlink RM4 Pro IR & RF Remote With Home Assistant - Hands-On Review - Tech TacticianTests infrared and radio-frequency control through Home Assistant after two years of use.Broadlink RM4 ProTech Tactician International2026Read Broadlink RM4 Pro IR & RF Remote With Home Assistant - Hands-On Review - Tech Tactician (opens in a new tab)
ReviewHue’s SpatialAware finally made me appreciate color-changing lightsFinds the upgrade compelling for households already invested in Hue.Philips Hue Bridge ProThe Verge United States2026Read Hue’s SpatialAware finally made me appreciate color-changing lights (opens in a new tab)
ReviewFlic Hub LR and buttons: a smart home still needs a physical clickTests hub and button operation together, including range and latency.Flic Hub LRThink Different International2026Read Flic Hub LR and buttons: a smart home still needs a physical click (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSwitchBot Hub Mini review: give old infrared… | Think DifferentA desk assessment of the infrared bridge and its limits.SwitchBot Hub MiniThink Different International2026Read SwitchBot Hub Mini review: give old infrared… | Think Different (opens in a new tab)
ReviewHomey Pro mini Review *Strong value for households that fit its app capacity and radio selection.Homey Pro miniTrusted Reviews United Kingdom2026Read Homey Pro mini Review (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonBest smart home systems in 2026: Reviews and buying advicePage headline says 2026; displayed update is September 2025.Samsung SmartThings Station — DIY hub for most peopleAmazon Echo Hub — dedicated control panel; IKEA Dirigera — beginnersPCWorld United States2025Read Best smart home systems in 2026: Reviews and buying advice (opens in a new tab)
ComparisonSmart-Home-Systeme im Test Mein Heim ist mein Butler14 systems. Scores apply to the systems as tested. Full scoring table paywalled; public result reported by teltarif.de.Homey and Home Assistant — joint winners, 2.3 eachStiftung Warentest Germany2025Read Smart-Home-Systeme im Test Mein Heim ist mein Butler (opens in a new tab)
ReviewMy favorite smart home device has a cheaper version now, and I love itRecommends the lower-priced model for most buyers beginning a smart home.Homey Pro miniAndroid Authority United States2025Read My favorite smart home device has a cheaper version now, and I love it (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSwitchBot Hub 3: recensione hub domotico 4-in-1 con Matter *Dedicated review of its Matter bridge, infrared control and physical controls.SwitchBot Hub 3CEOTECH Italy2025Read SwitchBot Hub 3: recensione hub domotico 4-in-1 con Matter (opens in a new tab)
ReviewTest: Homey Pro 2026 – Smart Hub’en til det seriøse Smart Home er forbedretHands-on review of the refreshed hardware.Homey Pro (2026)DIGITALT.TV Denmark2025Read Test: Homey Pro 2026 – Smart Hub’en til det seriøse Smart Home er forbedret (opens in a new tab)
ReviewTapo H110 Smart IR & IoT Hub review: Automate your homeRates the IR and IoT hub 8.4/10.TP-Link Tapo H110 8.4/10GadgetGuy Australia2025Read Tapo H110 Smart IR & IoT Hub review: Automate your home (opens in a new tab)
ReviewReview Philips Hue Bridge Pro: dé bridge voor de toekomstEvaluates the upgrade for Hue installations.Philips Hue Bridge ProID.nl Netherlands2025Read Review Philips Hue Bridge Pro: dé bridge voor de toekomst (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSwitchBot Hub 3: tutto il controllo della casa smart in un solo hub - InformareaPositive about ease of use and the range of integrated controls.SwitchBot Hub 3Informarea Italy2025Read SwitchBot Hub 3: tutto il controllo della casa smart in un solo hub - Informarea (opens in a new tab)
ReviewZooz Z-Box ReviewFirst-person member review; separate from the outlet’s editorial coverage.Zooz Z-BoxLinus Tech Tips community Canada2025Read Zooz Z-Box Review (opens in a new tab)
ReviewRecensione Aqara M3, l'hub matter è il telecomando smart per il tuo condizionatore - macitynet.itTests Matter integration and infrared control of air conditioning.Aqara Hub M3macitynet Italy2025Read Recensione Aqara M3, l'hub matter è il telecomando smart per il tuo condizionatore - macitynet.it (opens in a new tab)
ReviewThe SwitchBot Hub 3 review: A universal remote with an identity crisisQuestions how well its many control and sensor functions fit together.SwitchBot Hub 3Matter Alpha International2025Read The SwitchBot Hub 3 review: A universal remote with an identity crisis (opens in a new tab)
ReviewAqara Hub M100 review: Best value Matter hub | Matter AlphaStrong value for a compact Matter controller and bridge.Aqara Hub M100Matter Alpha International2025Read Aqara Hub M100 review: Best value Matter hub | Matter Alpha (opens in a new tab)
ReviewTEST: Homey Pro ’26 - Er Homey stadig kongen af smart home økosystemer? - recordere.dkFavorable assessment of the memory refresh and broader Homey ecosystem.Homey Pro (2026)recordere.dk Denmark2025Read TEST: Homey Pro ’26 - Er Homey stadig kongen af smart home økosystemer? - recordere.dk (opens in a new tab)
ReviewHomey & Homey Pro | TEST | Smarthome ohne Kompromisse?Tests cross-protocol integration and everyday automation.Homey Pro (Early 2023) and HomeySmarthomeAssistent Germany2025Read Homey & Homey Pro | TEST | Smarthome ohne Kompromisse? (opens in a new tab)
ReviewSwitchBot Hub 3, il centro di controllo smart home definitivo? | Test & Recensione - Tom's HardwareTests the dial, programmable buttons, sensors and daily automation.SwitchBot Hub 3Tom’s Hardware Italia Italy2025Read SwitchBot Hub 3, il centro di controllo smart home definitivo? | Test & Recensione - Tom's Hardware (opens in a new tab)
ReviewRecensione SwitchBot Hub 3: svolta decisiva verso l'eccellenza *Dedicated review of the third-generation SwitchBot hub.SwitchBot Hub 3TuttoAndroid Italy2025Read Recensione SwitchBot Hub 3: svolta decisiva verso l'eccellenza (opens in a new tab)
ReviewKleine instap naar groots platform — Homey Pro miniExamines the lower-cost entry to Homey’s local automation platform.Homey Pro miniTweakers Netherlands2025Read Kleine instap naar groots platform — Homey Pro mini (opens in a new tab)
ReviewTengo un nuevo control domótico de casa. Ahora sí comienzo a experimentar el poder de MatterDescribes using Matter, the control dial and sensors in the author’s home.SwitchBot Hub 3Xataka Smart Home Spain2025Read Tengo un nuevo control domótico de casa. Ahora sí comienzo a experimentar el poder de Matter (opens in a new tab)

Results use each publisher's own wording and apply to the products as tested at the time. Hub tests where several products were compared show the winner first, then other category picks. * Summary based on an excerpt: the full article could not be read. Country is where the outlet is based; “International” means an English-language site without one clear home country. Spotted a newer review? Email weknowsmarthome@gmail.com.